Is it possible that logging in with facebook has orphaned my existing account (that used the same email)? I tried password recovery, it only hooked me up to this new account. I know the old one still exists (I have the id) because I still have email notifications from replies to a question I answered.

I clicked the link in the email, browsed my original profile, it's all there, I just can't login using it. What do I do?

TIA, MM