Skip to main content
replaced http://serverfault.com/ with https://serverfault.com/
Source Link

I've had this come up a few times, and found some older answers to similar questions on meta.
However I believe that the answer heavily depends on the current moderator staff, as they are the ones handling these flags.

When I see an answer in the late answerslate answers queue, I check if the answer already exists.
If the answer has been directly copied word for word from another answer on the same question, I flag it as in need of moderator intervention. As the other flags don't fit at all.
I then add a link to the original answer.

Usually these flags get accepted.
Other times the flags get declined, but the answer is still deleted.
answers

As I am getting both positive and negative feedback on this way of flagging, I would appreciate some clarification.

Should I:

  1. Flag these
  2. Downvote them (seems counter-intuitive unless I also downvote the original)
  3. Ignore them (also seems counter-intuitive, they are not contributions, but bloat)

I've had this come up a few times, and found some older answers to similar questions on meta.
However I believe that the answer heavily depends on the current moderator staff, as they are the ones handling these flags.

When I see an answer in the late answers queue, I check if the answer already exists.
If the answer has been directly copied word for word from another answer on the same question, I flag it as in need of moderator intervention. As the other flags don't fit at all.
I then add a link to the original answer.

Usually these flags get accepted.
Other times the flags get declined, but the answer is still deleted.
answers

As I am getting both positive and negative feedback on this way of flagging, I would appreciate some clarification.

Should I:

  1. Flag these
  2. Downvote them (seems counter-intuitive unless I also downvote the original)
  3. Ignore them (also seems counter-intuitive, they are not contributions, but bloat)

I've had this come up a few times, and found some older answers to similar questions on meta.
However I believe that the answer heavily depends on the current moderator staff, as they are the ones handling these flags.

When I see an answer in the late answers queue, I check if the answer already exists.
If the answer has been directly copied word for word from another answer on the same question, I flag it as in need of moderator intervention. As the other flags don't fit at all.
I then add a link to the original answer.

Usually these flags get accepted.
Other times the flags get declined, but the answer is still deleted.
answers

As I am getting both positive and negative feedback on this way of flagging, I would appreciate some clarification.

Should I:

  1. Flag these
  2. Downvote them (seems counter-intuitive unless I also downvote the original)
  3. Ignore them (also seems counter-intuitive, they are not contributions, but bloat)
Tweeted twitter.com/ServerFault/status/761903331719704576
Source Link
Reaces
  • 5.6k
  • 14
  • 24

How to / should I flag exact copy answers

I've had this come up a few times, and found some older answers to similar questions on meta.
However I believe that the answer heavily depends on the current moderator staff, as they are the ones handling these flags.

When I see an answer in the late answers queue, I check if the answer already exists.
If the answer has been directly copied word for word from another answer on the same question, I flag it as in need of moderator intervention. As the other flags don't fit at all.
I then add a link to the original answer.

Usually these flags get accepted.
Other times the flags get declined, but the answer is still deleted.
answers

As I am getting both positive and negative feedback on this way of flagging, I would appreciate some clarification.

Should I:

  1. Flag these
  2. Downvote them (seems counter-intuitive unless I also downvote the original)
  3. Ignore them (also seems counter-intuitive, they are not contributions, but bloat)