Skip to main content
Shane Madden's user avatar
Shane Madden's user avatar
Shane Madden's user avatar
Shane Madden
  • Member for 13 years, 9 months
  • Last seen more than 4 years ago
revised
Loading…
revised
Loading…
comment
Community Promotion Ads - 2014
Been meaning to do this one for a while, no time like the present right?
answered
Loading…
comment
Community Promotion Ads - 2014
Keeping it going!
answered
Loading…
comment
accepted
asked
Loading…
awarded
comment
What's wrong with my question?
That's really more of a trivia question than anything - unless it applies to a problem you're having, then it's not really appropriate for Server Fault. In any case, then answer seems to be "because Microsoft wrote it that way". See here: msdn.microsoft.com/en-us/library/windows/desktop/…
comment
What's wrong with my question?
See the FAQ: You should only ask practical, answerable questions based on actual problems that you face. Please provide more background information about how you ran across this very interesting oddity in Windows name resolution, and how it applies to a problem you're having.
comment
Over-use of Off-Topic Closure
I don't think it is.. Adrain's not disagreeing that shopping questions should be closed, he's saying that Off Topic is the wrong close reason to use for them. - "Both should've been closed as NC for Shopping, not merely Off-Topic as that gives the impression that ALL questions about those topics are not welcome here."
comment
Over-use of Off-Topic Closure
I think the right close reason for shopping is Not Constructive - the close text for it makes a lot more sense on a shopping question than the Off Topic close text.
comment
List Questions - What to do with new ones
Aren't list questions the "polling" part of the not constructive close reason?
awarded
answered
Loading…
awarded
comment
Users with editing privileges can no longer approve edits
Fair enough - thanks for helping us understand the reasoning behind the change!
comment
What's our policy on questions regarding unreleased code?
Definitely this. Just because it doesn't have the "production seal of approval" from Redmond, doesn't mean that it's not being tested, evaluated, and pummeled by professionals looking to put it through its paces.
1
7 8
9
10 11
16