5

First: The question has been moved to superuser. In my opinion it should have been moved to serverfault. What can I do?

Second: I try to answer questions on iptables/netfilter. I end up answering questions on unix.stackexchange.com, serverfault.com, stackoverflow.com and now even superuser.com. It is very cumbersome since I've just started and I am missing reputation to do simple tasks.

What site do these questions really belong to and can I have them moved to that site?

Of course sometimes I answer with a netfilter-solution where it wasn't clear that this can be a solution. These question can stay where they are and so they can be answered using other solutions.

  • That one has now been moved back to SF. – John Gardeniers Mar 15 '11 at 21:28
4

What site do these questions really belong to and can I have them moved to that site?

From my point of view they potentially belong on all sites. These days firewalls exist at almost every level, and so it is reasonable for questions about them to come from both end-users and professional system administrators.

The difference in my mind is the context of the question. If someone is asking how to setup a host based firewall for their personal system, or how to adjust the firewall on their broadband router to permit their TF2 server to work, then it almost certainly belongs on superuser.

If they are asking about how to configure a network firewall on a Linux-based router for their business then it belongs on serverfault.

The particular question you linked to is sort of an usual case where it appears that someone is trying to use NAT and SSH to kludge a solution together. I can easily see how that may be migrated to superuser. I am not sure that the question as written fits here. What this guy seems to be trying to do, doesn't really give me a professional system-admin vibe.

Several users from serverfault where just complaining that we didn't want junk coming to serverfault, so perhaps it got moved to superuser to avoid us.

Anyway my point is that if you interested in answering questions about a specific topic at both the professional level, and the home-user level you will probably need to accept that you need to monitor serverfault, superuser, unix.se, ubuntu.se, and even security.se. I can see that this may be frustrating and having your rep distributed between the sites is a bit annoying, but the sites are split based on audience instead of just based on the specific topic.

4

You could flag the question and ask a mod on SU to move it but they are under no obligation to do so.

For this kind of question there is no real consensus beyond leaving them where they were asked as long as they are valid.

You must log in to answer this question.

Not the answer you're looking for? Browse other questions tagged .