How could they not be? Isn't that the whole point of SEs vs other systems? Objectivity and consistency?

As far as an inferential questions, it's more like I'm wondering why I should go to the Soup Nazi's place to get lunch. At this point, it's pretty obvious that I don't fit in to the technology SEs very well, and any attempts at figuring out why will probably get me perma-banned. However, I figured I would look around the SE to see if this SE could be a good fit, when I was flabbergasted at the top question. In other words, I'm testing the waters to see how Nazi-like the Soup Nazi is.