3

So, if the SE sites discourage link-and-run (or rather, encourage down-voting of LAR answers), why isn't this in the FAQ?

Earlier Meta discussions, showing that LAR is discouraged. Statistics: Current Ratio of "Link-And-Run" on the Stack Exchange Network

Reduce posting of "linking hit-and-runs" answers

Example of me assuming that such was in the FAQ, and now looking like a jerk (possibly because I'm a jerk.)

Publish jpg file as a ScreenSaver via GPO

Edit - I'm a silly man. This is actually in the FAQ, but you have to expand one of the answers. https://serverfault.com/faq#deletion

6

This is a general reference for link and run. I really don't think it warrants an entry in the faq, they are poor answers and we have the tools to deal with them.

  • Down vote it as a poor answer, and leave a comment, this is the one I generally use

We really do prefer that answers have content, not pointers to content. This ensures that the answer will remain available even if the link goes dead. Whilst this may theoretically answer the question, it would be preferable to include the essential parts of the answer here, and provide the link for reference.

  • Flag it as not an answer.

I'm more than happy to downvote, leave a comment and delete after the OP has had an opportunity to rectify the situation. I'm sure other mods are too.

3

Given all the trouble we went through, twice, to come up with the present FAQ and taking into consideration what was eventually not included I don't think this issue is serious enough to warrant an entry. I also doubt anyone is quite ready to go through the rewrite process again just yet.

OTOH, it might be worth a running question to discuss what might be included next time. That way we benefit from thought being put into it over a more extended time period. Remember that last time there were a bunch of suggestions when it was already too late.

  • I wasn't part of the discussion last time, so I'm not aware of the history. Link? I'm not sure if I should look for that stuff on the SO meta or on this one. – mfinni Jun 6 '12 at 13:54
  • Edited - It was already in the FAQ, but not visible without expanding a section – mfinni Jun 6 '12 at 14:01
  • @mfinni Re: the last FAQ rewrite, see these search results – voretaq7 Jun 6 '12 at 15:38

You must log in to answer this question.

Not the answer you're looking for? Browse other questions tagged .