3

sysadmin has ~300 questions and system-administration ~20

18

In my humble opinion the should be obliterated, and blacklisted. They seem like a meaningless meta-tag to me. If a question on SF isn't about system-administration/sysadmin then it is most likely off-topic.

I think we even discussed this before, and the consensus was to remove them, but nobody with the moderator access needed to do them all at once did it, but I can't find the post.

  • Have to agree. These tags ought to be redundant on this site. – Rob Moir Nov 2 '10 at 13:28
  • 1
    +1 Re-reading the FAQ, in particular the part about who SF is intended for, I have to agree. – John Gardeniers Nov 2 '10 at 22:11
  • I wonder if the discussion was back in the only-one-meta days; I'll see if I can find it on SO's meta. – Kara Marfia Nov 5 '10 at 13:55
3

When these things come up, sometimes I go to SO to see if if I can find analogous situations. Then I try to think of a justification.

Program, code, coding. This may be a larger question of, "Do we want to hunt down and kill redundant tags, or are some tags almost necessary because they represent a massive subsection of questions?"

(trying to play devil's advocate here) It might be useful to divide all SO questions into at least one major category: coding, scripting, version-control, etc. Which could imply that SF questions should always belong to either server mgmt, desktop mgmt, network mgmt, documentation (applies to both), etc.

I suppose that would make me lean more toward a merge than eradication. Sysadmin is such a loaded and nonspecific term, I'd probably synonym it to system-administration, which is at least a (possibly) manageable definition. Provided we could all someday agree on whether a "system" is a desktop and/or server and/or network and/or any "group of independent but interrelated elements comprising a unified whole".

This is where the SO analogies break down. It feels like they actually have more self-defining terms upon which they can agree (a statement I'll guess they'd find pretty humorous).

You must log in to answer this question.

Not the answer you're looking for? Browse other questions tagged .